Search databaseBooksAll DatabasesAssemblyBiocollectionsBioProjectBioSampleBioSystemsBooksClinVarConserved DomainsdbGaPdbVarGeneGenomeGEO DataSetsGEO ProfilesGTRHomoloGeneIdentical Protein web CatalogNucleotideOMIMPMCPopSetProteinProtein ClustersProtein family ModelsPubChem BioAssayPubChem CompoundPubChem SubstancePubMedSNPSRAStructureTaxonomyToolKitToolKitAllToolKitBookgh Bookshelf. A service of the nationwide Library that Medicine, national Institutes of Health.

You are watching: Descriptive properties of things in the problem domain are often documented as what?

National research study Council; department of Behavioral and Social Sciences and Education; commission on Behavioral and Social Sciences and also Education; Committee on basic Research in the Behavioral and also Social Sciences; Gerstein DR, Luce RD, Smelser NJ, et al., editors. The Behavioral and Social Sciences: achievements and Opportunities. Washington (DC): national Academies press (US); 1988.


National study Council; department of Behavioral and also Social Sciences and Education; commission on Behavioral and also Social Sciences and Education; Committee on straightforward Research in the Behavioral and also Social Sciences; Gerstein DR, Luce RD, Smelser NJ, et al., editors.

This chapter concerns research top top collecting, representing, and evaluating the data the underlie behavioral and social sciences knowledge. Such research, methodological in character, includes ethnographic and also historical approaches, scaling, axiomatic measurement, and also statistics, v its necessary relatives, econometrics and also psychometrics. The field can be described as including the self-conscious research of just how scientists draw inferences and also reach conclusions indigenous observations. Because statistics is the largest and also most prominent of methodological approaches and is used by researcher in virtually every discipline, statistical occupational draws the lion’s re-publishing of this chapter’s attention.

Problems that interpreting data arise whenever inherent variation or measure fluctuations create challenges to understand data or to judge whether it was observed relationships room significant, durable, or general. Part examples: Is a sharp monthly (or yearly) boost in the rate of juvenile delinquency (or unemployment) in a particular area a matter for alarm, an ordinary periodic or random fluctuation, or the an outcome of a adjust or quirk in reporting method? do the temporal patterns seen in such repeated monitorings reflect a straight causal mechanism, a facility of indirect ones, or simply imperfections in the data? Is a to decrease in auto injuries an result of a new seat-belt law? space the disagreements amongst people relenten some aspect of a subculture too great to attract valid inferences around that element of the culture?

Such concerns of inference are regularly closely associated to substantive theory and details data, and to some level it is daunting and perhaps misleading come treat approaches of data collection, representation, and analysis separately. This report walk so, as perform all scientific researches to some extent, because the methods emerged often space far more general than the specific problems that originally gave rise to them. Over there is much transfer of new ideas indigenous one substantive field to another—and to and from fields outside the behavioral and also social sciences. Several of the timeless methods of statistics emerged in researches of huge observations, biological variability, and also human diversity. The major growth the the timeless methods emerged in the twenty century, greatly engendered by troubles in agriculture and genetics. Some techniques for uncovering geometric frameworks in data, such together multidimensional scaling and factor analysis, source in study on emotional problems, yet have been applied in many other sciences. Some time-series methods were arisen originally to attend to economic data, yet they are equally applicable to countless other type of data.

Within the behavioral and social sciences, statistical methods have been developed in and also have contributed to one enormous selection of research, including:
In economics: large models of the U.S. Economy; effects of taxation, money supply, and other government fiscal and also monetary policies; theories of duopoly, oligopoly, and rational expectations; financial effects the slavery.
In psychology: test calibration; the development of spatu probabilities, their revision in the irradiate of new information, and also their use in decision making; psychiatric epidemiology and also mental wellness program evaluation.
In sociology and also other fields: victimization and crime rates; effects of incarceration and also sentencing policies; deployment the police and fire-fighting forces; discrimination, antitrust, and regulatory court cases; social networks; population growth and also forecasting; and also voting behavior.

Even such an abridged listing provides clear that improvements in methodology are an important across the spectrum the empirical research in the behavioral and also social sciences as well as in application to policy questions. Clearly, methodological research serves numerous different purposes, and also there is a require to develop different viewpoints to offer those various purposes, consisting of exploratory data analysis, clinical inference about hypotheses and population parameters, separation, personal, instance decision making, forecasting what will occur in the occasion or absence of intervention, and also assessing origin from both randomized experiments and also observational data.

This conversation of methodological research is divided into 3 areas: design, representation, and also analysis. The efficient style of investigations have to take place prior to data are built up because it entails how much, what sort of, and how data are to be collected. What type of examine is feasible: experimental, sample survey, field observation, or other? What variables need to be measured, controlled, and also randomized? How extensive a topic pool or observational duration is appropriate? How deserve to study resources be allocated most effectively among various sites, instruments, and also subsamples?

The building of beneficial representations the the data entails deciding what sort of officially structure ideal expresses the underlying qualitative and also quantitative ideas that are being used in a offered study. For example, expense of living is a simple concept to quantify if it applies to a single individual with unchanging tastes in stable sectors (that is, sectors offering the same selection of products from year to year at varying prices), but as a national aggregate for numerous households and constantly an altering consumer product markets, the price of living is not simple to specify clearly or measure reliably. Statisticians, economists, sociologists, and other experts have lengthy struggled to do the expense of life a precise yet practicable ide that is also efficient come measure, and they should continually modify it to reflect changing circumstances.

Data evaluation covers the last step that characterizing and also interpreting research study findings: Can approximates of the relations in between variables be made? have the right to some conclusion it is in drawn around correlation, cause and effect, or trends over time? how uncertain space the estimates and also conclusions and can that skepticism be decreased by analyzing the data in a different way? Can computer systems be supplied to display complex results graphically for much faster or far better understanding or come suggest various ways of proceeding?

Advances in analysis, data representation, and also research architecture feed into and reinforce one another in the course of actual clinical work. The intersections between methodological improvements and empirical advancements are crucial aspect the the multidisciplinary thrust of progress in the behavioral and also social sciences.

Designs for Data Collection

Four vast kinds of study designs are offered in the behavioral and social sciences: experimental, survey, comparative, and ethnographic.

Experimental designs, in either the laboratory or ar settings, systematically manipulate a couple of variables while others the may impact the outcome are hosted constant, randomized, or otherwise controlled. The purpose of randomized experiment is come ensure that only one or a couple of variables have the right to systematically influence the results, therefore that reasons can it is in attributed. Inspection designs incorporate the arsenal and analysis of data from censuses, sample surveys, and also longitudinal studies and the check of miscellaneous relationships among the observed phenomena. Randomization theatre a different function here than in speculative designs: it is used to choose members that a sample so the the sample is together representative the the whole population as possible. Comparative draft involve the retrieval of evidence that is taped in the circulation of existing or past occasions in different times or places and the translate and analysis of this evidence. Ethnographic designs, additionally known as participant-observation designs, indicate a researcher in intensive and direct contact with a group, community, or population being studied, v participation, observation, and also extended interviewing.

Laboratory Experiments

Laboratory experiments underlie many of the work reported in chapter 1, far-reaching parts of thing 2, and some the the newest lines of research in chapter 3. Laboratory experiments extend and also adapt classical methods that design very first developed, because that the most part, in the physical and also life scientific researches and farming research. Your main feature is the systematic and independent manipulation the a couple of variables and the strict manage or randomization the all various other variables the might influence the phenomenon under study. For example, some researches of animal an ideas involve the systematic manipulation of quantities of food and also feeding schedule while other components that might also influence motivation, such together body weight, deprivation, and also so on, are hosted constant. Brand-new designs are currently coming right into play largely because of brand-new analytic and computational methods (discussed below, in “Advances in statistical Inference and also Analysis”).

Two instances of empirically important worries that show the require for broadening classical experimental approaches space open-ended responses and lack of independence of successive experimental trials. The very first concerns the style of research study protocols that perform not need the strict segregation the the events of an experiment into well-defined trials, however permit a topic to respond in ~ will. These techniques are needed when what is of interest is how the respondent chooses to allocate actions in actual time and across continuously obtainable alternatives. Together empirical methods have actually long to be used, but they have the right to generate very subtle and complicated problems in speculative design and subsequent analysis. Together theories that allocative behavior of every sorts become an ext sophisticated and also precise, the experimental requirements become much more demanding, so the require to better understand and solve this range of style issues is an outstanding an obstacle to methodological ingenuity.

The second issue occurs in repeated-trial designs once the habits on successive trials, also if that does no exhibit a secular trend (such together a discovering curve), is markedly affected by what has happened in the coming before trial or trials. The more naturalistic the experiment and the more sensitive the meas urements taken, the more likely it is the such effects will occur. But such sequential dependencies in observations cause a number of important conceptual and technical troubles in summarizing the data and also in testing analytical models, which space not yet fully understood. In the absence of clean solutions, such effects are sometimes ignored through investigators, simple the data evaluation but leaving residual water of skepticism about the reliability and also significance that the experimental results. V continuing breakthrough of sensitive procedures in repeated-trial designs, over there is a growing need for an ext advanced concepts and also methods for managing experimental outcomes that might be affected by sequential dependencies.

Randomized ar Experiments

The state the the art in randomized ar experiments, in which various policies or measures are tested in managed trials under actual conditions, has advanced dramatically end the past two decades. Difficulties that were as soon as considered major methodological obstacles—such together implementing randomized ar assignment come treatment and also control groups and protecting the randomization procedure indigenous corruption—have been greatly overcome. While cutting edge standards room not completed in every ar experiment, the appointment to getting to them is increasing steadily, no only among researchers but also among customer agencies and also sponsors.

The wellness insurance experiment described in chapter 2 is an example of a major randomized ar experiment that has had and will proceed to have essential policy reverberations in the style of health treatment financing. Ar experiments v the negative income taxation (guaranteed minimum income) carried out in the 1970s were significant in policy debates, even before their completion, and provided the many solid evidence easily accessible on exactly how tax-based income support programs and also marginal tax prices can impact the work incentives and also family frameworks of the poor. Necessary field experiment have also been lugged out on different strategies because that the avoidance of delinquency and also other criminal behavior, revolutionary of court procedures, rehabilitative programs in mental health, household planning, and also special educational programs, amongst other areas.

In planning field experiments, much hinges ~ above the an interpretation and architecture of the speculative cells, the specific combinations needed of treatment and also control conditions for each collection of demography or other customer sample characteristics, including specification of the minimum variety of cases essential in each cell come test because that the existence of effects. Considerations of statistics power, customer availability, and the theoretical framework of the inquiry get in into such specifications. Present important methodological thresholds room to find much better ways the predicting recruitment and attrition fads in the sample, of creating experiments that will certainly be statistically robust in the confront of problematic sample recruitment or extreme attrition, and also of ensuring proper acquisition and evaluation of data on the attrition ingredient of the sample.

Also of significant significance are renovations in completely detailed process and outcome dimensions in ar experiments. Come conduct research study on program results under field conditions requires continual monitoring come determine precisely what is gift done—the process—how it coincides to what to be projected in ~ the outset. Relatively unintrusive, inexpensive, and effective implementation measures are of great interest. Over there is, in parallel, a farming emphasis on creating experiments come evaluate distinctive program materials in comparison to an introduction measures that net program effects.

Finally, over there is crucial opportunity now for additional theoretical occupational to version organizational processes in social settings and also to design and also select outcome variables that, in the reasonably short time the most ar experiments, have the right to predict longer-term effects: because that example, in job-training programs, what are the effects on the community (role models, morale, referral networks) or on separation, personal, instance skills, motives, or expertise levels that are likely to interpret into sustained transforms in job paths and also income levels?

Survey Designs

Many people have opinions about how societal mores, economic conditions, and also social programs form lives and also encourage or discourage assorted kinds of behavior. Civilization generalize indigenous their very own cases, and from the groups to which castle belong, around such problem as just how much it expenses to raise a child, the extent to which unemployment contributes to divorce, and also so on. In fact, however, impacts vary so lot from one group to one more that homespun generalizations are of small use. Fortunately, behavioral and also social scientists have actually been maybe to bridge the gaps between personal perspectives and also collective realities by means of inspection research. In particular, governmental details systems encompass volumes that extremely an important survey data, and also the basic of modern-day computers come store, disseminate, and also analyze together data has significantly improved empirical tests and led to brand-new understandings of society processes.

Within this category of study designs, two significant types are distinguished: repeated cross-sectional surveys and longitudinal dashboard surveys. In addition, and also cross-cutting this types, there is a major effort under method to improve and refine the high quality of inspection data through investigating functions of human being memory and also of question development that impact survey response.

Repeated cross-sectional designs have the right to either attempt to measure an entire population—as go the oldest U.S. Example, the nationwide decennial census—or they deserve to rest top top samples drawn from a population. The general principle is to take independent samples at 2 or an ext times, measure the variables that interest, together as earnings levels, housing plans, or opinions about public affairs, in the exact same way. The general Social Survey, gathered by the nationwide Opinion Research facility with nationwide Science structure support, is a repeated cross sectional data base the was begun in 1972. One methodological inquiry of certain salience in together data is just how to readjust for nonresponses and “don’t know” responses. One more is how to resolve self-selection bias. For example, to to compare the income of women and also men in the labor force, it would certainly be mistake to an initial assume that the 2 samples of labor-force participants are randomly selected indigenous the larger populations the men and women; instead, one needs to consider and also incorporate in the analysis the determinants that determine who is in the job force.

In longitudinal panels, a sample is drawn at one allude in time and also the relevant variables space measured at this and also subsequent times for the same people. In more complicated versions, some fraction of each panel might be changed or included to periodically, together as expanding the sample to include households formed by the children of the initial sample. An example of panel data emerged in this method is the Panel study of earnings Dynamics (PSID), conducted by the college of Michigan due to the fact that 1968 (discussed in chapter 3).

Comparing the fertility or earnings of different people in various circumstances at the very same time to find correlations constantly leaves a large proportion of the variability unexplained, but common sense suggests that much of the unexplained variability is actually explicable. There space systematic reasons for separation, personal, instance outcomes in each person’s previous achievements, in parental models, upbringing, and earlier order of experiences. Unfortunately, questioning people about the past is not specifically helpful: human being remake their views that the past to rationalize the present and also so retreat data are regularly of unsure validity. In contrast, generation-long longitudinal data permit readings top top the succession of previous circumstances uncolored by later outcomes. Together data room uniquely beneficial for examining the reasons and results of naturally emerging decisions and transitions. Thus, as longitudinal research studies continue, quantitative evaluation is becoming feasible around such questions as: exactly how are the decisions of individuals influenced by parental experience? Which elements of at an early stage decisions constrain later opportunities? and how does in-depth background experience leave that is imprint? Studies like the two-decade-long PSID room bringing within master a complete generational bicycle of thorough data top top fertility, work-related life, family members structure, and income.

Advances in Longitudinal Designs

Large-scale longitudinal data collection projects are uniquely valuable as vehicles for testing and also improving survey research study methodology. In methods that lie beyond the border of a cross-sectional survey, longitudinal studies have the right to sometimes be designed—without far-ranging detriment to your substantive interests—to facilitate the evaluation and also upgrading that data quality; the evaluation of loved one costs and also effectiveness of different techniques that inquiry; and also the standardization or coordination of services to problems of method, concept, and measurement throughout different study domains.

Some locations of methodological development include discoveries about the affect of interview setting on an answer (mail, telephone, face-to-face); the effects of nonresponse ~ above the representativeness that a sample (due come respondents’ refusal or interviewers’ failure to contact); the impacts on behavior of continued participation gradually in a sample survey; the value of different methods of adjusting because that nonresponse and also incomplete observations (such together imputation of missing data, variable case weighting); the influence on response of specifying different recall periods, differing the intervals in between interviews, or changing the length of interviews; and the comparison and calibration the results obtained by longitudinal surveys, randomized field experiments, activities studies, onetime surveys, and also administrative records.

It have to be especially detailed that incorporating improvements in methodology and data quality has actually been and also will no doubt continue to be vital to the growing success of longitudinal studies. Dashboard designs space intrinsically more vulnerable than other designs to statistics biases as result of cumulative item non-response, sample attrition, time-in-sample effects, and also error spare part in repeated measures, all of which may produce exaggerated estimates of change. Over time, a panel the was originally representative may end up being much less representative that a population, no only because of attrition in the sample, but likewise because of alters in immigrant patterns, period structure, and the like. Longitudinal research studies are also subject to transforms in scientific and also societal contexts the may produce uncontrolled drifts gradually in the an interpretation of nominally stable concerns or concepts and also in the underlying behavior. Also, a natural tendency to increase over time the selection of topics and thus the interview lengths, which increases the burdens top top respondents, might lead to degradation of data high quality or relevance. Careful methodological study to understand and also overcome these difficulties has been done, and also continued job-related as a ingredient of brand-new longitudinal researches is specific to advancement the overall state that the art.

Longitudinal research studies are periodically pressed for proof they space not designed to produce: for example, in important public policy questions concerning the impact of government programs in such locations as health promotion, an illness prevention, or criminal justice. By using research study designs that integrate field experiment (with randomized assignment to program and also control conditions) and also longitudinal surveys, one have the right to capitalize ~ above the the strongest merits that each: the experimental component provides stronger evidence for casual statements that are an important for evaluating programs and also for illuminating some fundamental theories; the longitudinal component helps in the estimate of permanent program effects and their attenuation. Coupling experiments to continuous longitudinal studies is not frequently feasible, given the lot of constraints of not disrupting the survey, developing all the complex arrangements that get in a large-scale ar experiment, and having the populations of attention overlap in beneficial ways. Yet avenues to join ar experiments to surveys room of great importance. Coupled studies have the right to produce vital knowledge about the empirical problems under i m sorry the outcomes of longitudinal surveys revolve out to be similar to—or divergent from—those developed by randomized field experiments. A sample of divergence and also similarity has begun to arise in coupled studies; added cases are essential to understand why some naturally developing social processes and also longitudinal style features seem to approximate formal arbitrarily allocation and also others carry out not. The methodological effects of such new knowledge walk well past program evaluation and survey research. This findings bear directly on the trust scientists—and others—can have in conclusions indigenous observational studies of facility behavioral and social processes, an especially ones the cannot be controlled or simulated within the boundaries of a activities environment.

Memory and also the frame of Questions

A very important possibility to enhance survey methods lies in the palliation of nonsampling error because of questionnaire context, phrasing the questions, and, generally, the semantic and social-psychological elements of surveys. Inspection data are an especially affected by the fallibility of human memory and also the sensitivity of respondent to the structure in i m sorry a inquiry is asked. This sensitivity is especially solid for certain types of attitudinal and opinion questions. Efforts are now being make to carry survey specialists right into closer contact with researchers functioning on memory function, expertise representation, and language in order to uncover and reduce this kind of error.

Memory for occasions is frequently inaccurate, biased towards what respondents believe to it is in true—or should be true—about the world. In many instances in i m sorry data are based upon recollection, improvements deserve to be achieved by moving to approaches of structured interviewing and calibrated develops of memory elicitation, such as specifying recent, brief time durations (for example, in the last seven days) within which respondents recall certain varieties of occasions with acceptable accuracy.

Experiments on separation, personal, instance decision making display that the way a inquiry is framed predictably transforms the responses. Experts of survey data find that some little changes in the wording of particular kinds the questions deserve to produce large differences in the answers, although other wording alters have small effect. Also simply an altering the stimulate in which some questions are presented have the right to produce huge differences, although for other questions the stimulate of presentation does no matter. Because that example, the following questions were amongst those asked in one wave of the general Social Survey:
“Taking points altogether, just how would you define your marriage? would certainly you say the your marriage is an extremely happy, quite happy, or not also happy?”
“Taken altogether just how would you speak things space these days—would you say you are very happy, pretty happy, or not too happy?”

Presenting this succession in both directions on various forms confirmed that the order affected answers to the basic happiness question yet did not adjust the marital delight question: responses come the details issue swayed succeeding responses come the basic one, yet not evil versa. The explanations for and implications of such order impacts on the countless kinds that questions and sequences that deserve to be supplied are not straightforward matters. Further trial and error on the design of survey instruments promises not just to boost the accuracy and also reliability of survey research, but also to development understanding that how people think around and evaluate their actions from day to day.

Comparative Designs

Both experiments and also surveys involve interventions or inquiries by the scientist, who then records and also analyzes the responses. In contrast, numerous bodies of social and behavioral data of substantial value are originally derived from records or collections that have accumulated for assorted nonscientific reasons, quite often bureaucratic in nature, in firms, churches, armed forces organizations, and governments at all levels. Data that this kind can sometimes it is in subjected to mindful scrutiny, summary, and inquiry by historians and also social scientists, and also statistical methods have actually increasingly been used to develop and also evaluate inferences drawn from together data. Some of the key comparative ideologies are cross-national aggregate comparisons, selective compare of a minimal number the cases, and also historical instance studies.

Among the more striking difficulties facing the scientist using such data space the vast differences in what has been videotaped by various agencies whose behavior is being compared (this is particularly true for parallel agencies in various nations), the extremely unrepresentative or idiosyncratic sampling the can happen in the repertoire of such data, and the selective preservation and destruction of records. Way to overcome these problems type a considerable methodological research agenda in comparative research. An instance of the an approach of cross-national aggregative to compare is uncovered in investigate by politics scientists and also sociologists that the factors that underlie distinctions in the vitality of establishments of politics democracy in different societies. Part investigators have stressed the visibility of a large middle class, others the level of education and learning of a population, and still rather the advancement of equipment of massive communication. In cross-national aggregate comparisons, a huge number of countries are arrayed according to some measures of political democracy and then attempts are made come ascertain the toughness of correlations between these and the various other variables. In this heat of evaluation it is feasible to usage a selection of statistics cluster and regression techniques to isolate and assess the possible impact of specific variables on the establishments under study. If this sort of research study is cross-sectional in character, statements about historical procedures are regularly invoked to define the correlations.

More limited selective comparisons, used by numerous of the standard theorists, show off asking comparable kinds that questions yet over a smaller range of societies. Why go democracy build in such various ways in America, France, and England? Why walk northeastern Europe build rational bourgeoes capitalism, in comparison to the Mediterranean and Asian nations? modern-day scholars have turned their fist to explaining, for example, distinctions among species of fascism in between the two world Wars, and also similarities and also differences among modern-day state welfare systems, making use of these comparisons come unravel the important causes. The inquiries asked in these instances space inevitably historic ones.

Historical case studies involve just one country or region, and so they may not be geographically comparative. However, insofar as they show off tracing the revolution of a society’s major institutions and the function of its key shaping events, they involve a compare of different periods the a nation’s or a region’s history. The score of together comparisons is to offer a systematic account of the appropriate differences. Sometimes, specifically with respect come the ancient societies, the historic record is an extremely sparse, and the methods of history and archaeology mesh in the reconstruction of complex social arrangements and patterns of adjust on the communication of few fragments.

Like all research study designs, comparative ones have actually distinctive vulnerabilities and also advantages: one of the main benefits of making use of comparative design is that they greatly increase the selection of data, and also the quantity of sport in those data, for study. Consequently, they permit for much more encompassing explanations and also theories that can relate extremely divergent outcomes to one another in the exact same framework. They also contribute come reducing any social biases or tendencies toward parochialism among scientists studying common human phenomena.

One main vulnerability in such designs arises from the problem of afford comparability. Due to the fact that comparative study involves studying societies and also other units that are dissimilar from one another, the phenomena under examine usually happen in an extremely different contexts—so various that in some instances what is called an event in one culture cannot really be pertained to as the same form of occasion in another. For example, a vote in a western democracy is various from a vote in an eastern bloc country, and a voluntary vote in the joined States means something different from a compulsory poll in Australia. These scenarios make because that interpretive difficulties in comparing aggregate rates the voter turnout in different countries.

The difficulty of achieving comparability appears in historical evaluation as well. Because that example, transforms in laws and also enforcement and recording actions over time adjust the definition of what is and also what is not a crime, and for that reason it is an overwhelming to compare the crime rates over time. To compare researchers battle with this problem continually, working to fashion identical measures; part have said the usage of various measures (voting, letters to the editor, street demonstration) in different societies for typical variables (political participation), to shot to take contextual determinants into account and also to attain truer comparability.

See more: Which Of The Following Classifications Of Viruses Can Change Its Own Code To Avoid Detection

A second vulnerability is controlling variation. Classic experiments do conscious and elaborate initiatives to regulate the variation of part factors and thereby assess the causal definition of others. In surveys and also experiments, statistical approaches are provided to regulate sources that variation and also assess doubt causal significance. In comparative and historical designs, this sort of manage is often daunting to achieve because the sources of variation space many and the number of cases few. Scientists have made initiatives to approximate such control in these cases of “many variables, small N.” One is the technique of combine comparisons. If an investigator isolates 15 American urban in which racial violence has actually been recurrent in the previous 30 years, because that example, it is beneficial to enhance them with 15 cities of similar population size, geographical region, and also size of minorities—such attributes are controls—and then find for organized differences between the two sets the cities. Another method is come select, because that comparative purposes, a sample of cultures that resemble one one more in certain an essential ways, such as size, typical language, and common level of development, hence attempting to host these factors around constant, and also then search explanations among other determinants in i beg your pardon the sampled cultures differ native one another.