Share every sharing alternatives for: Clay Matthews’ controversial roughing the passer contact on Kirk Cousins has actually everyone confused


The eco-friendly Bay Packers looked to have their game against the Minnesota Vikings locked up after Kirk Cousins threw an interception down by eight points with 1:45 left on the clock. Instead, Packers linebacker Clay Matthews was referred to as for roughing the passer, a punish that extended the journey and enabled the Vikings to tie the game.

You are watching: Clay matthews hit on kirk cousins video

This was the call in question:

La pénalité en question. Clay Matthews fou de rage après le match. Compréhensible

— NFL France (

After the penalty, the Vikings marched best down the ar for a touchdown pass to Adam Thielen and also a two-point conversion to Stefon Diggs that tied the video game at 29.

Nothing about this call makes sense

There was nothing ~ the initial hit by Matthews. That hit Cousins clean in the chest together the round was released. It no look like he arrived on Cousins v his human body weight, yet apparently the ref believed differently. Nevertheless, the call was made and the interception to be wiped out.

Referee Tony Corrente explained it after the game. Unfortunately, his explanation won’t leave anyone, specifically Packers fans, with lot satisfaction.

Here’s the complete referee pool report as transcribed by the NFL:

— plunder Demovsky (
RobDemovsky) September 16, 2018

Take an additional look at the video. Does it look to you choose Matthews choose up Cousins and also drove him right into the ground? No. Cousins’ feet perform leave the ground, so possibly that’s what the refs saw. However, together the video clip makes clear it’s Matthews’ momentum combined with Cousins in the plot of cram that offers him a lift.

The NFL is was standing by the call, though

Senior Vice chairman of Officiating Al Riveron will protect Corrente’s call and even pass it approximately to all 32 groups as a teach lesson:

alriveron, the Sr. VP of Officiating, will send a out weekly teaching video clip to every clubs (and game officials) that states referee Tony Corrente make right contact on
packers Clay Matthews" controversial roughing the passer penalty. Much more coming on Monday NFL Countdown

— kris Mortensen (
mortreport) September 17, 2018

But Dean Blandino and Mike Pereira room the two guys who previously organized Riveron’s position, and both disagree v the call.

NFL officiating chiefs
MikePereira and also
DeanBlandino issued strong rebuttals today to the league’s emphasis on roughing the QB, especially the two calls in MIN-GB. Pertinent transcript:

— Kevin Seifert (
SeifertESPN) September 17, 2018

‘I don’t understand what rather to do.”

Here’s what Matthews stated after the game external of his locker:

“I mean, ns don’t even know where to start to be fully honest v you. There are so plenty of emotions running through (me) as much as what a terrible call it was, but at the exact same time, i don’t understand what else to do. Ns don’t know, you let me know. Did i put push on him? since I believed I struggle him within the belt to chest (area). I got my head across, put my hand down and also to speak to it in ~ that suggest in the game is unbelievable.

”Last week, ok, shame on me, however this week — it is unbelievable and also the worst component is, we’ll more than likely send the in and you understand what they room going come say — they’ll uncover fault ~ above me since they space going come agree with the refs. I don’t know. The a complicated call come call and you saw exactly how it adjusted the game and also I recognize there’s an emphasis on protecting quarterbacks yet it’s obtained out of control now.”

“A small bit the gray area”

“I think that’s whereby a small bit of gray area is in the judgment of the defender hitting the quarterback,” Packers coach Mike McCarthy claimed the following day.

“I acquire what the goal (of player safety) is, and also we’re all for the goal being achieved, yet at the same time, you have to make certain it’s no a vain disadvantage come the happen rusher trying come hit the quarterback.”

McCarthy didn’t object come the usage of prompt replay in that situation, either.

Room for interpretation

Here’s the entire roughing the passer rule:

A rushing defender is prohibited from committing together intimidating and also punishing acts together “stuffing” a passer into the soil or unnecessarily wrestling or steering him down after the passer has actually thrown the ball, also if the rusher provides his initial contact with the passer in ~ the one-step limitation detailed for in (a) above. As soon as tackling a passer who is in a defenseless attitude (e.g., throughout or just after throw a pass), a defensive player should not unnecessarily or violently throw him under or floor on top of him through all or most of the defender’s weight. Instead, the protective player have to strive come wrap increase the passer through the protective player’s arms and not floor on the passer through all or most of his body weight.

See more: How Many Days Until May 30 2019 ? How Many Days Since May 30, 2019

It leaves a many room because that interpretation, particularly that last component of it. At the very least one former official made the perfectly clear.

I’ll just say this now: if the two hits top top the QB in #MINvsGB are certainly fouls for roughing the passer, i am happy that ns am no longer on the field and also have to do those calls.

— terry McAulay (

The game was expanded into overtime after ~ the Packers to let go a 52-yard ar goal. Luckily, or unluckily depending on your rooting interest, the Vikings missed a game-winning 35-yard field in overtime to complete with a 29-29 tie.

It’s worth noting below that the 29-29 last score is an NFL first, a scorigami!

A tie’s better than a loss, yet that won’t leaving anyone in this video game feeling lot satisfaction, specifically Packers fans. Green Bay had actually it nearly wrapped up, yet a bad call changed the outcome of the game.